First Venture Apply

The honest question

Is a passion project worth it for college?

Admissions officers say they do not require one. The admissions industry sells them anyway. Both are telling the truth, and the gap between them is where the answer lives.

What the people who read applications say

When parents ask on forums whether their kid "actually needs" a passion project or whether that is just industry talk, the answer from admissions staff and experienced counselors is consistent. Nobody is required to have one. A project that was foisted on a student is worse than no project. Nobody in an admissions office is sitting around saying the phrase "passion project." They are reading what a student did and asking whether it was real.

The same people say something else, in the same breath. Depth of commitment matters more than scope. A student who pursued something with genuine interest, showed growth, and affected someone outside themselves, however small the scope, is noticed. That is a passion project, by any other name.

So: worth it or not?

It depends entirely on which of two things you mean.

A project done to have a project is not worth it. It costs a summer, often money, and it produces something that experienced readers recognize on sight: a nonprofit started in June, a research paper on a topic the student never mentioned before, an app with no users. Readers say they can often tell from the start date alone. The student knows too, which is its own cost.

A project the student would have done anyway, carried far enough that someone outside the family touched it, is worth it on its own terms. If it helps an application, that is because it is evidence of something true. If it does not, the student still has the thing.

The test

Ask three questions about any project, proposed or finished.

  1. Would the student do this if no college ever saw it? If the honest answer is no, stop.
  2. Does something exist that did not before, and can a stranger find it? A site, a dataset, a product, a recurring event. Not a plan.
  3. Did anyone outside the family use it, and how do you know? A number with a denominator, from a source you can show.

Three yeses and it is worth doing regardless of what any admissions office thinks. Three nos and it is a line on a form. One or two yeses and you know what to fix.

The cost side

A passion project done alone costs time and a small amount of money: a domain, maybe a payment account, some materials. Done through a paid program it costs considerably more. The question to ask a program is what exists at the end that would not exist otherwise, and whether the student made the decisions or executed someone else's template. We wrote up the arithmetic in how much a passion project costs.

The time side

Counselors keep pointing at the start date because it carries information. A project with eighteen months of history reads differently from one with eight weeks. If you are a sophomore, this is good news: start now, start small, and let it have a history. If you are a rising senior, the honest move is a short project with a sharp ending and a record of what happened, and no pretense that it was years in the making.

What to tell a student who is on the fence

Pick the smallest version of the thing you already want to make, and give it two weeks. If after two weeks you have a page that is up, one number written down, and a reason to keep going, keep going. If you have a document about what you are going to build, stop, and spend the summer on a job or a class instead. Both of those are respectable, both are honest, and neither requires pretending.

What "worth it" looks like in practice

A student who ran a thing for six weeks, took one payment from a stranger, kept a dated public log, and wrote a frank final entry about why it did not grow, has something worth having. It is small. It is true. It can be checked by anyone with a browser. Compare that with a certificate from a program that admitted everyone who paid, and the question answers itself.

If you already have a project and want to know which kind it is, we read them. For how to describe one once it exists, see how to write about a passion project in the Common App.

Have a project already? Send it for a free written read and we will tell you where it stands.